 |
| FACT CHECK: Clinton's latest gun-law broadside on Sanders |
FACT CHECK: Clinton's latest gun-law broadside on Sanders
With New York's acute presidential nominating challenge looming, Democratic applicant Hillary Clinton is framing gun laws in Bernie Sanders' home accompaniment of Vermont as a primary culprit of agitated abomination in the Empire State.Her latest offensive, however, depends on a attenuated and arguably extraneous use of federal gun data.
Speaking on Long Island, New York, this week, Clinton said that if Sanders is "challenged on his gun stances, he frequently says: 'Well, I represent Vermont. It's a small, rural state.'"
Clinton added: "Here's what I wish you to know: Most of the accoutrements that are acclimated in crimes and abandon and killings in New York appear from out of state. The accompaniment that has the accomplished per-capita amount of those accoutrements that end up committing abomination in New York appear from Vermont."
That drew aural gasps from her audience, convened by the attack to allocution accurately about gun laws.
For months, Clinton has acclimated the gun affair to casting Sanders as a beloved for gun makers and out of footfall with a Democratic primary electorate that favors tighter accoutrements restrictions. While technically correct, her latest allegation relies on a anxiously crafted framing of statistics.
The U.S. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Accoutrements compiles abstracts about weapons recovered from abomination scenes nationwide, forth with data, area possible, about area those accoutrements were originally awash by accountant dealers. The bureau letters that in 2014, law administration admiral in New York recovered and traced 7,686 guns.
The accompaniment itself was the antecedent for 1,397 of the weapons, authoritative it the baton in complete numbers. Virginia was runner-up, with 395. Vermont ranked 15th on the list, accounting for 55 of the weapons — beneath than 1 percent of the total.
 |
| FACT CHECK: Clinton's latest gun-law broadside on Sanders |
By comparison, adjoining Pennsylvania accounted for 371 of the recovered weapons in New York. But with its citizenry of 12.8 million, Pennsylvania's per capita addition was one weapon for every 34,508 residents.
John Roman, a chief adolescent at the Urban Institute, said Clinton's assay was statistically actual but focused on the amiss numbers. "It doesn't amount how abounding humans reside in Vermont. It affairs how abounding bad gun dealers there are," Roman said.
He said even just two bad dealers could calmly be amenable for the 55 accoutrements traced in New York in 2014. More important, he said, is analytical area and how accoutrements move about the country, such as via the "Iron Pipeline." The alleged activity funnels accoutrements from states with looser gun laws to those with austere bounded regulations, such as New York and New Jersey.
The Sanders attack criticized Clinton's tactic. "No admiration so abounding humans say they don't assurance her," agent Michael Briggs said via email, abacus that Vermont contributes alone a "tiny atom of the all-embracing out-of-state guns" recovered annually in New York.
A abstracted Sanders attack account aswell acclaimed that Clinton has accustomed abutment from Vermont Gov. Peter Shumlin, who said, "I anticipate you'd accept a harder time acceptable Vermonters that New York's abomination problems are advancing from Vermont."
Clinton's attack says the allegory still is relevant. Because Vermont is a part of states with the atomic barriers to gun purchases, aides say, it is accomplished for exporting weapons to states like New York, which boasts some of the nation's toughest weapons regulations. They say that makes Clinton's case on the charge for tougher civic regulations that administer beyond all states.
0 comments:
Post a Comment